Slice 2013 13 of 31: Love It or Loathe It


Last week I worked with two reluctant writers in an after-school support program. Their regular teacher had a family emergency just an hour or so before the end of the day, and was in quite a panic. I told her not to worry, to go home and I would take care of her students. After she left, I had a brief “What was I thinking?” moment, then realized that I knew exactly how we’d spend the hour.


I recently bought a copy of Marvelous Minilessons for Teaching Intermediate Writing, Grades 4-6, by Lori Jamison Rog (International Reading Association, 2011). In the first chapter, Rog provides a concise but thorough overview of the writing workshop. The rest of the book is organized by topics such as prewriting, elaboration, craft, and specific genres. The chapter on prewriting had an activity that I was sure would engage these students. They both loved to talk and had plenty to say, but had difficulty getting their thoughts down on paper.  “Love It or Loathe It” is essentially a two column chart that allows students to generate lists of things they really love or really loathe. As we know, and as Rog points out, “the best writing comes from topics that a writer feels strongly about” (p. 33). To help them get started, I shared my “Love It or Loathe It” list.

        Love It       Loathe It
  • my family
  • my dog, Lucy
  • my cat, Noodles
  • chocolate
  • reading
  • writing
  • knitting
  • walking
  • swimming
  • baking
  • injustice
  • meanness
  • being wasteful
  • bitter foods, olives in particular
  • being late
  • not having enough time to read more books
  • living 7 hours away from my son & daughter-in-law
  • procrastination

It took them a few minutes, but once they got started, they produced quite a lengthy list. We had a lively conversation around their topics, with an item from one student’s “Love It” list reminding the other of something they loathed. After about 10 minutes, they chose a topic to write about. When the hour was up, they didn’t want to stop and took their writing home to keep working. That’s the way I love to end a lesson.

What do you love? What do you loathe?

Thank you to Stacey and Ruth at Two Writing Teachers for hosting this Slice of Life Challenge!

4 thoughts on “Slice 2013 13 of 31: Love It or Loathe It

  1. Oh love this! I will make a love it and loath list for one of my future slices. I also, want to share this with students. Thanks for sharing!


  2. Thanks for this great strategy. I can see how reluctant writers would be engaged. hmmm… I love yoga, snow in December and crocuses in March. I love sleeping in which rarely happens and eating dinner with friends. I love my kids and writing stories. I loathe baseball, people who are mean-spirited, injustice, and beets–I wish I loved them, I really do. I loathe busyness and to-do lists (even though they are necessary.)


  3. Thank you for sharing this. What a great strategy. My students are doing the classroom challenge and this may help them be more inspired! Sharing it tomorrow!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s